
Ys turns 20: is it Joanna Newsom's masterpiece, or is Have One on Me?
Five songs in 55 minutes against eighteen in two hours. Newsom fans have been split on this since 2010, and we're picking a side.
DebateRiffiter5 min read
Ys, Joanna Newsom's second album, was released by Drag City on November 14, 2006: five long songs for harp and voice, with orchestral arrangements by Van Dyke Parks on four of them. Its follow-up, the triple album Have One on Me (2010), runs 18 songs and just over two hours. Fans and critics have argued over which is her masterpiece ever since; this is the case for each.
Joanna Newsom's Ys turned 20 on Saturday. Drag City put it out on November 14, 2006: five songs, 55 minutes, harp and voice with an orchestra written around them. Three years and three months later came Have One on Me, eighteen songs across three discs, a little over two hours. Put a room of Newsom fans together and ask which one is the masterpiece, and you will find the room has been split since February 2010.
The critics are no help. Pitchfork gave Ys a 9.4 and Have One on Me a 9.2. Metacritic has both at 85. The charts went the opposite way from what you'd guess: the two-hour triple album charted higher than Ys in both the US and the UK. So we have to settle it ourselves.
Where she started
The Milk-Eyed Mender (2004) is where people decided whether they could stand the voice. It's harp, a bit of piano and a singer who cracked and yelped in places trained singers are taught to avoid, on songs like "Sadie" and "Peach, Plum, Pear" that were short enough to get away with it. It sits in our freak folk canon, which is where most people filed her in 2004. She didn't stay there for long.
The case for Ys
Start with how it was made, because that's the argument. Newsom recorded her harp and vocals with Steve Albini in December 2005. The orchestra came five months later, in May and June 2006, arranged by Van Dyke Parks, whose 1967 album Song Cycle was why she asked him in the first place. Jim O'Rourke mixed it. Every bar of strings on Ys was written around a performance that was already finished. Parks couldn't ask her to leave a gap or hold a tempo; he had to find room inside what she had already played. That's why the arrangements wind around the vocal instead of sitting under it, and why the record doesn't sound like a singer-songwriter album with an orchestra added. It sounds like one long piece that happens to have two authors.
The songs are long because the stories need the space. "Emily" runs twelve minutes and is named for her sister, who sings on it. "Only Skin" goes for nearly seventeen, and partway through Bill Callahan's voice comes in to answer hers. Roy Harper's Stormcock (1971), four long songs and not much else, was part of the model for the album's scale.
"Sawdust & Diamonds" is the one song Parks didn't touch: ten minutes of harp and voice. If you want to know whether Ys is for you, start there. The orchestra is what the other four are famous for, but this track shows the songs never needed it to hold together.
The case for Ys, then, is that it's a finished object made by a method that could only work once. You can hear exactly how it was put together and still not quite believe it was.
The case for Have One on Me
In the spring of 2009 Newsom developed nodules on her vocal cords and spent about two months unable to speak or sing. The voice that came back on Have One on Me was lower and steadier. Reviewers noticed it straight away. For a lot of listeners it was the whole story: the yelp that sent people out of the room in 2004 was mostly gone, and in its place was a singer who could carry a nine-minute song without leaning on strangeness to do it.
The method changed as well. Ryan Francesconi arranged and conducted, Neal Morgan played drums, and Newsom produced it herself. These are band arrangements built with the songs, not orchestration laid over a finished take. Eighteen songs, six to a disc, 124 minutes. "Good Intentions Paving Co." is the nearest she has come to a pop single and a good argument that she should try again. "'81" is under four minutes and as plain as she gets. "Baby Birch" runs nine and a half minutes and is the best thing on the record, and the hardest to sit through.
So the case for Have One on Me is generosity. It's warmer and easier to put on, and it contains more great songs than Ys contains songs at all. That last point is a cheap shot, but it holds up.
The case against it is the running time. Our double albums guide counts it among the records that earn their extra discs, and we stand by that, but a triple album asks for a whole evening, and it's fair to wonder how many people would miss disc three.
And then Divers
Divers (2015) is eleven songs and fifty minutes, and it tends to get mentioned when someone wants to end this argument by changing the subject. It's still her most recent album. She has been playing new songs live since 2024, and there's no record yet.
Our pick
Ys. We'd hand Have One on Me to someone who has never heard her, and we'd defend disc one against almost any singer-songwriter record of its decade. But Ys is the one where the making of it can't be separated from the music. A finished harp-and-voice performance, then an arranger spending months writing an orchestra into the spaces she left, and five songs that don't sound like anything before or after them, including her own later records. Her voice changed in 2009 and she made a different, very good kind of album. She couldn't have made Ys again, and neither could anyone else.
You'll also find Ys in our chamber pop canon, filed with the records that taught pop how to use strings.
Rate both above. If you think the triple album wins, the comments are open: tell us which disc you'd keep if you had to lose two.
Discussion
Disagree? Have a better record in mind? Say it — top takes rise.
Sign in to join the discussion.
No one's weighed in yet. Go first.