Skip to content

Guides/A Riffiter guide

Christmas albums for people who hate Christmas music: 16 records that took the job seriously

Jazz trios, Stax instrumentals, a Takoma guitarist, a slowcore band, and one Mariah Carey record we will defend in the comments.

The Christmas albums that hold up for people who dislike holiday music are the ones where the artist treated the season as material rather than a sales window. This guide collects 16 released between 1960 and 2015, including Vince Guaraldi Trio's A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965), John Fahey's The New Possibility (1968), Low's Christmas (1999) and Sufjan Stevens' five-EP box Songs for Christmas (2006).

Most Christmas albums are obligations: a label needs something for the fourth quarter and somebody books a string section in July. The records below were made by people who either took the assignment seriously or used it as cover to try something their regular albums couldn't hold. A jazz trio scored a cartoon about a depressed kid. A slowcore band wrote a song about taking the tree down.

They run in release order, from 1960 to 2015. Two are huge sellers, Mariah Carey's among them, and we think it earns its place. Most are records you can put on in the second week of December without anyone in the room groaning.

The usual first pick, the 1963 Philles Wall of Sound album, is missing on purpose. Its producer was convicted of murder in 2009. There are sixteen other ways to get through the month.

  1. 1
    Ella Wishes You a Swinging Christmas artwork

    Ella Wishes You a Swinging Christmas

    Ella Fitzgerald

    Be the first to rate

    A Christmas record cut in New York between mid-July and early August 1960, with Norman Granz producing and Frank DeVol arranging and conducting. It swings like any other Ella date of the period, which is the point. 'Good Morning Blues' sits between 'The Christmas Song' and 'Let It Snow!' as if nobody checked the theme, and the album is better for it.

  2. 2
    The Nutcracker Suite (Expanded Edition) artwork

    The Nutcracker Suite (Expanded Edition)

    Duke Ellington

    Be the first to rate

    Ellington and Billy Strayhorn took Tchaikovsky's 1892 ballet and renamed the movements like nightclub numbers: 'Sugar Rum Cherry', 'Toot Toot Tootie Toot', 'Arabesque Cookie'. Columbia recorded it in Los Angeles over five dates in May and June 1960. It's the most overplayed music of the season handed to an orchestra that clearly found the whole idea funny. Play 'Sugar Rum Cherry' to anyone who says they never need to hear the Sugar Plum Fairy again.

  3. 3
    Christmas '64 artwork

    Christmas '64

    Jimmy Smith

    Be the first to rate

    Creed Taylor producing for Verve, Rudy Van Gelder engineering in Englewood Cliffs, Billy Byers arranging the big-band tracks and Kenny Burrell on guitar for much of it. Smith's Hammond does to 'God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen' what it did to everything else he touched, which is make it greasy. Verve reissued it in 1966 as Christmas Cookin', a better title and a more honest one.

  4. 4
    The Beach Boys' Christmas Album artwork

    The Beach Boys' Christmas Album

    The Beach Boys

    Be the first to rate

    Two records sharing a sleeve. Side one is Brian Wilson producing his own band on originals like 'Little Saint Nick' and 'The Man with All the Toys', both written with Mike Love. Side two gives the standards to a 41-piece orchestra arranged and conducted by Dick Reynolds, and you can skip it. Capitol put it out on November 9, 1964, weeks before Wilson stopped touring, and side one already sounds like the work of someone who'd rather be in the studio.

  5. 5
    A Charlie Brown Christmas artwork

    A Charlie Brown Christmas

    Vince Guaraldi Trio

    Be the first to rate

    The one even the Christmas-averse own, and the one with the least Christmas in it. 'Linus and Lucy' had already been recorded for a Guaraldi album in 1964, 'Skating' is about ice, and 'Christmas Time Is Here' is a lullaby with something sad underneath it. The children's choir came from St. Paul's Episcopal Church in San Rafael, recorded over several evenings at Fantasy's San Francisco studio for five dollars a kid, and they sound exactly like children, which is why it works. Fantasy released it in December 1965, timed to the TV special.

  6. 6
    In the Christmas Spirit artwork

    In the Christmas Spirit

    Booker T. & The MG's

    Be the first to rate

    The Stax house band in 1966, which means Booker T. Jones on organ, Steve Cropper on guitar, Duck Dunn on bass and Al Jackson Jr. on drums, playing carols the way they played every session that came through McLemore Avenue. It's instrumental, about 34 minutes, produced by Jim Stewart. 'Merry Christmas Baby' and 'Blue Christmas' already had the blues in them, and this band doesn't have to look hard to find it.

  7. 7
    Someday at Christmas artwork

    Someday at Christmas

    Stevie Wonder

    ★ 3.5 · 1

    Wonder was 17 when Tamla released it in November 1967. The title song, by Ron Miller and Bryan Wells, came out as a single a year earlier and is a Vietnam-era prayer dressed as a carol: someday there'll be no wars, someday at Christmas. 'What Christmas Means to Me' is the other reason to own it, the one you'll hear in shops every December without ever getting sick of it.

  8. 8
    The New Possibility: John Fahey's Guitar Soli Christmas Album artwork

    The New Possibility: John Fahey's Guitar Soli Christmas Album

    John Fahey

    Be the first to rate

    Solo steel-string guitar on Takoma, the label Fahey started himself, with carols played in the same fingerpicked style as his own pieces. It became his best-selling record, past 100,000 copies on its first run and in print ever since. Fahey liked the idea enough to re-record the set as Christmas Guitar, Volume One and to make more Christmas albums later. 'Christ's Saints of God' runs past ten minutes and is where the hymn stops and Fahey takes over.

  9. 9
    Christmas Portrait artwork

    Christmas Portrait

    Carpenters

    Be the first to rate

    Richard Carpenter produced and co-arranged it, with Peter Knight adapting much of the orchestral writing, and the sessions moved between A&M in Los Angeles and Abbey Road in London. The 'Overture' medley strings eight carols together like the curtain going up on a stage musical. Karen asked to re-sing 'Merry Christmas Darling', their 1970 single, for the album, and that low, unhurried vocal is the reason to own the album. The session leftovers became An Old-Fashioned Christmas in 1984, the year after she died.

  10. 10
    Merry Christmas artwork

    Merry Christmas

    Mariah Carey

    ★ 3.6 · 120

    Yes, this one. 'All I Want for Christmas Is You', written and produced with Walter Afanasieff, is the reason a lot of people hate Christmas music, and it is also a very well built pop song with bells everywhere and a vocal that holds back until it doesn't. The rest of the album has two more Carey and Afanasieff originals, 'Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)' and 'Jesus Born on This Day', plus a gospel streak co-produced by Loris Holland. Columbia released it in 1994; the RIAA certified it Diamond in December 2025.

  11. 11
    Christmas artwork

    Christmas

    Low

    ★ 4.0 · 1

    Eight songs on Kranky, released November 16, 1999 as a gift to fans, under half an hour, five of them originals. 'Just Like Christmas' is the most cheerful thing Alan Sparhawk and Mimi Parker ever put on tape, and 'Blue Christmas' gets slowed to Low's own pace until it sounds like one of theirs. 'Taking Down the Tree' is named for the chore nobody writes carols about. The A.V. Club called it the religious album even heathens can love, and nobody has improved on that.

  12. 12
    Songs for Christmas artwork

    Songs for Christmas

    Sufjan Stevens

    Be the first to rate

    Five EPs Stevens made as gifts for friends and family between 2001 and 2006, skipping 2004 because he was busy with Illinois. Asthmatic Kitty boxed them on November 21, 2006: 42 songs, stickers, a Rick Moody essay and a sing-along book. Sincere carols sit next to originals like 'That Was the Worst Christmas Ever!' and 'Did I Make You Cry on Christmas Day? (Well, You Deserved It!)', which is as close as indie rock gets to an actual family Christmas, arguments included. Silver & Gold added 58 more songs in 2012.

  13. 13
    One More Drifter in the Snow artwork

    One More Drifter in the Snow

    Aimee Mann

    Be the first to rate

    Released on SuperEgo, Mann's own label, in October 2006 and produced by her bassist Paul Bryan, it's half an hour of slow, lamplit arrangements. It opens with Jimmy Webb's 'Whatever Happened to Christmas?'. Her husband Michael Penn wrote 'Christmastime', and 'Calling on Mary', co-written with Bryan, belongs with her best songs of the decade. Grant-Lee Phillips narrates the Grinch song, which is as strange as it sounds.

  14. 14
    Christmas in the Heart artwork

    Christmas in the Heart

    Bob Dylan

    ★ 5.0 · 1

    Recorded in Santa Monica in May 2009, produced by Dylan under the name Jack Frost, with royalties going to Feeding America, Crisis and the World Food Programme. Critics spent that winter asking whether it was a joke, and Dylan said it wasn't. His voice on 'Here Comes Santa Claus' is the strongest evidence for both readings. The accordion-and-polka 'Must Be Santa' has a video that settles nothing.

  15. 15
    Tinsel and Lights artwork

    Tinsel and Lights

    Tracey Thorn

    Be the first to rate

    Thorn picked songs for people who already own the canon: Joni Mitchell's 'River', Randy Newman's 'Snow', Sufjan Stevens' 'Sister Winter', the White Stripes' 'In the Cold, Cold Night' and Low's 'Taking Down the Tree', sung with Green Gartside, who also wrote 'Snow in Sun' for her. Ewan Pearson produced and Ben Watt plays on most of it. Her own 'Joy' has the Thorn and Watt kids on backing vocals, and it's the one original here that could stand next to the covers she chose.

  16. 16
    It's a Holiday Soul Party artwork

    It's a Holiday Soul Party

    Sharon Jones and the Dap-Kings

    Be the first to rate

    Daptone's band at full strength in 2015, opening with '8 Days (Of Hanukkah)', which Jones introduced as a Hanukkah soul song, and following it with 'Ain't No Chimneys in the Projects', the question every kid in a tower block has asked. 'Funky Little Drummer Boy' does what the title says. It was the band's first holiday record and turned out to be their last: Jones died in November 2016.

Comments