Skip to content

Riffiter.New Concerts

Search artists, albums, and songs

one who moves through music

Discover

New releases
Artists
Genres
Charts
Concerts
Lists
Blog
Guides
News

Tools

Last.fm taste report
Import from RateYourMusic
Daily music games
Add to the catalog

Riffiter

About
Privacy
Terms
Cookies

Elsewhere

X
Instagram
Spotify

Riffiter.

© 2026 Riffiter · Made in Istanbul

Metadata & artwork from MusicBrainz, TheAudioDB, and Cover Art Archive. Listening sync via Last.fm.

Home
Charts
Log
Activity
Sign in

Track09/40· 4:10

Make Believe It's Your First Time

Your rating

—

Write a review →

Not yet rated. Be the first.

Home
/
Carpenters
/
Gold: 35th Anniversary Edition
/
Make Believe It's Your First Time

Listen on

Spotify
Apple Music
YouTube Music

Watch

Watch on YouTube

Your review

—

Lyrics

← PreviousSing Next →Your Baby Doesn't Love You Anymore

Community

This track page is built by listeners — ratings, reviews, and even the data come from people like you.

Suggest an edit →How to contribute →

On Gold: 35th Anniversary Edition

2004 · 40 tracks

01Superstar3:47
01Yesterday Once More3:59
02Rainy Days and Mondays3:35
02Please Mr. Postman2:48
03Top of the World3:02
03Hurting Each Other2:48
04Maybe It's You3:03
04I Need to Be in Love3:50
05Merry Christmas Darling3:08
05Let Me Be the One2:26
06(They Long to Be) Close to You3:42
06Reason to Believe3:04
07Jambalaya (On the Bayou)3:39
07All You Get From Love Is a Love Song3:48
08Leave Yesterday Behind3:33
08Sing3:18
09Make Believe It's Your First Time4:10
09Your Baby Doesn't Love You Anymore3:51
10Bless the Beasts and Children3:15
10Ticket to Ride4:10
11Goodbye to Love3:57
11It's Going to Take Some Time2:59
12I Just Fall in Love Again4:04
12The Rainbow Connection4:37
13Only Yesterday3:47
13I Believe You3:56
14Sweet, Sweet Smile3:02
14Tryin' to Get the Feeling Again4:23
15There's a Kind of Hush (All Over the World)3:05
15For All We Know2:33
16California Dreamin'2:31
16Touch Me When We're Dancing3:21
17Solitaire4:42
17I Won't Last a Day Without You3:56
18We've Only Just Begun3:05
18Mr. Guder3:22
19A Song for You4:38
19This Masquerade4:54
20Karen's Theme2:41
20Calling Occupants of Interplanetary Craft (The Recognized Anthem of World Contact Day)7:09