American Girls · Counting Crows
24 albums similar to American Girls by Counting Crows (2026), ranked by listening overlap between artists, shared genres and era.

Dulcinea
Toad the Wet Sprocket
1994

Bringing Down the Horse
The Wallflowers
1996

Cracked Rear View
Hootie & The Blowfish
1994

Yourself or Someone Like You
Matchbox Twenty
1996

Collected 1996-2005
The Wallflowers
2009

P.S. (A Toad Retrospective)
Toad the Wet Sprocket
1999

Maroon
Barenaked Ladies
2000

Sparkle and Fade
Everclear
1995

Feeling Strangely Fine
Semisonic
1998

More Than You Think You Are
Matchbox Twenty
2002

Fairweather Johnson
Hootie & The Blowfish
1996

Throwing Copper
Live
1994

Somewhere More Familiar
Sister Hazel
1997

Let Your Dim Light Shine
Soul Asylum
1995

Villains
The Verve Pipe
1996

Third Eye Blind
Third Eye Blind
1997

Everything You Want
Vertical Horizon
1999

America Town
Five for Fighting
2000

New Miserable Experience
Gin Blossoms
1992

Hits From Yesterday & The Day Before
Barenaked Ladies
2011

The Rockville LP
O.A.R.
2014

Overboard
The Verve Pipe
2014

Glad All Over
The Wallflowers
2012

So Much for the Afterglow
Everclear
1997
Back to American Girls